I wish I could tell you everything. I wish I could make you understand. I will always love you, Niko. And maybe some part of you will always be able to feel that. That's what I'll tell myself, anyway. I don't want to, but I know we have to say good-bye.
Mel to Niko before wiping her memory of ever knowing her.

Other Women is the fifth episode of the first season of Charmed and the fifth episode of the series overall. It premiered on November 11, 2018.[1]


GUILT — Mel (Melonie Diaz) is worried about Niko’s (Ellen Tamaki) safety, so Mel and Harry (Rupert Evans) come up with a plan to protect her, but Mel will need her sisters’ help. Maggie (Sarah Jeffery) notices that Macy (Madeleine Mantock) is upset about her situation with Galvin (Ser'Darius Blain), so she offers to do some recon with her, but they discover that things might not be exactly what they seem. Meanwhile, Maggie’s sorority sister Lucy (guest star Natalie Hall) turns to her for some help, but Maggie struggles with telling her the truth because it could jeopardize her sorority future. [2]


This article is a stub and needs to be expanded.


Main Cast

Recurring Cast

Guest Cast


Magical Notes

Book of Shadows

  • Invoking the Moirai
    • The Charmed Ones found this powerful spell to alter history, and used it to erase Mel's relationship with Niko in order to protect the latter.



  • Telekinesis: Macy’s primary power. Used to send Harry flying out of the bathroom, used to knock a picture off a wall in the science lab, used to break a beer bottle, and finally used to lift the back of Summer’s shirt. 
  • Telepathic Empathy: Maggie’s primary power. Used to hear Lucy’s thoughts. Used to read Macy’s mind. 
  • Temporal Stasis: Mel’s primary power. Used to attempt to freeze Hellflame twice. Used to freeze Hunter and Niko several times alongside a tray and a syringe in the hospital. Used to freeze Niko again at the Vera house.
  • Teleportation: Used by Harry to teleport to the hospital.
  • Remote Hearing: Used by Harry to hear Mel's call.
  • Shapeshifting: Used by Hunter to impersonate Trip and a nurse.
  • Smoking: Used by Hunter to enter Trip's grave and transport using a smoke like form.
  • Flight: Used by Hunter to move through the air as a smoke.
  • Supernatural Strength: Used by Hunter to hurl Niko across a room and render her unconscious (with one hand); and to throw Mel against the hospital room wall.
  • Resistance: Used by Hunter to break out of Temporal Stasis. He is also capable to survive lethal injection, which was going to kill the mortal Niko.
  • Magic Sense: Used by Hunter and Alastair to detect the 'temporal shift' of The Charmed Ones' spell to rewrite time - though not the details of the shift.


  • Book of Shadows: The Elders took it back to their headquarters to inspect potential hidden spells. When Mel's girlfriend became the target of a powerful shape-shifting demon, they requested it back and used a powerful spell in it to alter history.
  • Hellflame: Used by Hunter for attempt to murder Niko Hamada.
  • Mystical mark: The mysterious glowing red symbol, which Macy sees on Galvin's skin.


  • This episode also marks the first time the sisters meet a shapeshifter.
  • This is the first episode to feature spells fully in English.
  • Harry has moved into the Vera Manor as of this episode.
  • This was the first episode of the series to not feature a demon vanquish of any kind.

Unanswered Questions

  • What kind of mark is on Galvin?
  • What will Maggie do now that she is out of Kappa?
  • What will happen to Niko?
  • What will Mel do now that she loses her teaching assistant job due to time shift?
  • What was Harry's previous life like?
  • What is Alastair Caine scheming?

 Answered Questions From Previous Episode(s)

  • Who was the mysterious man who took the Harbinger?
    • The man is Alastair Caine, a demon who poses as the CEO of Morningstar Biotech and a benefactor to the Department of Genetics at Hilltowne University.
  • Why did Charity frame Trip Bailey?
    • She did it to hide the existence of the magic world from mortals.
  • What will happen between Maggie, Parker and Lucy?
    • Parker leaves Lucy because of his feelings for Maggie. After all, Maggie tells her the truth and now Lucy hates them both.

References to the Original Charmed

  • Hunter Caine is the first shapeshifter demon to appear in the series. In the original series, the first shapeshifter demon was Marshall.
  • In the original series, shapeshifters could take on the form of anyone they could imagine.
  • In the original series, a Succubus was a former witch who made a pact with darkness. Succubi give up all human emotions and become predators, seeking powerful men to feed off their testosterone. The Charmed Ones faced a Succubus named Darla in the episode "She's a Man, Baby, a Man!".

Production Notes

  • The episode was watched by 0.95 million U.S. Viewers.





  • Fading Out by Ivory Circle
  • Spell On Me by VenessaMichaels (ft. Leslyn & Outlaw The Artist)
  • Mention by Desta French
  • No Better by Raveena
  • The Edge by Anna Mae
  • La Favorita – L’ai-je Bien Entendu by APM Studio Musicians and Singers



See Also